Consultant talking to female patient about knee replacement

New survival data for fixed bearing knee implants is good news if you’re 60 or under and need a knee replacement.

To date, most knee replacements have been performed in the over-60s. In part, that’s because the wear and tear that knee replacements solve occurs most frequently in older patients. But that’s far from the complete picture. Over the years we’ve seen many people under 60 – sometimes as young as 45 – who are in desperate need of knee replacement. Often, we’ve had to delay.

Replacing the replacements

The problem was never in the here and now. A knee replacement, partial or total, could benefit any patient. But we know from National Joint Registry data that younger people who have joint replacements tend to wear them out quicker than people who have their knee replacement later in life. The reason for that is, typically, younger people place greater demands on their knees than older people.

Think of it like wear on a car tyre. Travel the length and breadth of the country frequently and you’ll need a new set of tyres far sooner than if your driving tends to be limited to the occasional local outing.

We know more than 80% of total knee replacements last for 25 years or longer, and that partial knee replacements can last 15-20 years, can be more cost effective, require shorter hospital stays and that patient outcomes and satisfaction can be even better than for total replacements. But whatever the average survival rate for a knee replacement, it was typically lower for younger, more active patients.

Why implant survival matters

This short implant lifespan presented a real problem. When a partial knee implant fails, you can’t simply swap it out for another one. You need to progress to a total knee replacement, and once that reaches the end of its working life the choices become far more limited. The next stage is revising the total knee replacement, which is a more complex and risky procedure. Pain relief following the procedure is usually lower and general outcomes far less predictable.

>  Most knee replacements now last 25 years
>  Discover more about knee replacement surgery

If you think of that in terms of an active patient who had a partial knee replacement at 50, the fear was always that we would run out of effective knee replacement options whilst they were somewhere in their 70s. And then what? You can see why knee surgeons were uncomfortable about performing any knee replacement in younger people. We always had one eye on the future.

Partial knees last longer

So the findings of a study by (amongst others) myself and my colleague Professor Nick London should provide encouraging reading for knee surgeons and younger patients alike.

We reviewed 91 knees fixed bearing medial partial knee implants in 70 patients aged 60 or under and found 92.9% of them survived to 10 years, and 87.8% survived to 15 years. 97% of patients said they were pleased or very pleased with their knees. The report concludes that the study “demonstrates low complication rates, good-to-excellent long-term patient outcomes, and satisfactory implant survival”.

This is great news because it gives patients and surgeons confidence that partial knee replacements, even in relatively young patients, can last a long time when done properly. That in turn pushes the need for a total knee replacement further into the future and means partial knee replacement is an increasingly viable option for a younger, more active age group.

We’re continuing to follow these patients and will report again as the cohort reaches 20 years with their implants.

In the meantime, if you’ve been told that you can’t have a knee replacement because you’re under 60, the evidence now says otherwise. Talk to us.

>  Discover more about Dave Duffy
>  Discover more about Prof. Nick London
>  Discover more about knee replacement surgery

Talk to the Yorkshire Knee Clinic specialist surgeons about your knee condition

Visit The Knowledge Hub

Helpful information about knee conditions, injuries, treatments & recovery

Prof. Nick London

Prof. Nick London

Specialist Knee Surgeon & Visiting Professor to Leeds Beckett University

“An excellent knee ­surgeon. He probably does as many partial knee replacements as anyone in the country.”

Click here to read the Daily Mail Good Doctors Guide

Dave Duffy

Dave Duffy

Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon & District NHS Foundation Trust

“Mr Duffy is a wonderful knee surgeon but he’s a very approachable guy as well… That makes a huge difference.”

Jean Drake,
YKC patient.

Internet Explorer is no longer supported.